Dishonoring our Veterans
Did you ever send in a rebate coupon on a store purchase and never receive the money you were promised? It's infuriating to be deceived, and insulting to be disrespected. Especially when what was promised to you winds up in the hands of people who don't need or deserve the money.
That New Mexico should single out those who have made the greatest sacrifices for our country for this kind of treatment is a disgrace. Yet that is what the Legislature has done by passing HB 97, the New Mexico Veteran Business and Contractor Preference, and HB 10 the Veteran Employment Tax Credit during the 2012 legislative session. Along the way, we have demonstrated much of what is wrong with our current political process.
Advertised as giving a leg up to returning vets from Iraq and Afghanistan, these bills will instead waste millions on subsidies and tax breaks to businesses that don't need them.
HB 97 was sold as helping returning vets get established in business by granting 2 - 5% bidding preferences to veteran-owned businesses competing for contracts across state government. Unfortunately, the law does nothing to distinguish returning veterans from veterans that already have established successful businesses. Millions could be spent on subsidies to established business owners who need no help. Even worse, non-veteran-owned companies will game the law to hijack veterans' preference money. They will finance shell corporations naming a veteran as the owner, and the shell companies will subcontract the work back to the existing non-veteran owned company. It's not hard to see unscrupulous operators lining up to soak the government on this one. Not only will this law do little to help honest returning veterans, we will dishonor their name with a taxpayer rip off.
HB 10, proposes to incent business owners to hire veterans by offering a $1,000 tax credit for each veteran hired. In practice, the tax credit is too small to have a significant influence on hiring decisions. Employers will simply take the credit on veterans they would have hired anyway, and once again little benefit will accrue to the heroes the legislation purports to help. Unfortunately I voted yes on this bill. I wish I could take that vote back.
These bills passed because no legislator wants to face charges in the upcoming election that they voted against veterans. HB 10 passed unanimously through both houses, and I was the only no vote on HB 97. Many legislators did not understand or have time to consider how these bills would actually work in practice. They were presented as routine housekeeping on the Senate floor during the crush of bills that were held back until the last two days of the session.
In addition, the objective legislative analysis that is supposed to come from the legislative finance committee utterly failed to highlight the relevant issues in the case of HB 97. HB 97 was analyzed as having minimal to no cost. How the government can pay an additional two to five percent preference and incur no cost remains a mystery to me.
Assisting returning veterans is a goal worthy of our investment. If we truly wish to help them find a place in our economy we should enhance their educational, job training and job placement benefits rather than shelling out money to businesses that may not have their best interests at heart. Hopefully we will fix or repeal HB 10 and HB 97 in the future. Political gestures that create the illusion of helping vets not only dishonor our heroes, they cost taxpayers a bundle. Veterans and taxpayers deserve better than deceptive and possibly corrupt politics. They deserve effective policy.
Steve Fischmann is the State Senator for district 37, Dona Ana and Sierra counties. |
 |
» Dishonoring our Veterans
» An Affront to Your Wallet and Your Civil Rights
» Undo Citizens United Now
» Time to focus on jobs
» Children's Reading Foundation of Doņa Ana County
» Budget full of goodies -
if you live out of State
» Legislature: Leave the Santa
Costumes At Home
» Waste Not, Want Not
» Let's Teach the Right
Lessons in Our Schools
» Food Tax
» Education: Getting Back
to basics can't hurt
» Coercion is not
Free Speech
» Protection of the
Otero Mesa
» Let's Not Waste
the Budget Crisis
» End Giveaways in
New Mexico's Budget
» Steve introduces bill
to reform TIDDs
» 2009 Legislative Session
» Fischmann's Election
Shifts Local Delegation
» Movers and shakers:
Steve Fischmann
» Las Cruces Bulletin: Steve
Fischmann prepares for
first session in Santa Fe
» 4 steps to energy
independence:
Steve Fischmann is leading
the
way to energy and
economic independence
in New Mexico
» Fischmann Op-Ed on
State Land Office Deals
|